Finding the right catcher's mitt usually starts with pocket preference, glove size, and break-in characteristics. Catchers often evaluate mitts based on receiving feel, durability, and how the pocket handles repeated impacts throughout a season. Leather quality and construction can influence both longevity and break-in time.


Wilson
Wilson A1000 CM33 Model 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt with SuperSnakeSkin
Sale price$199.95
Only 2 units left

Rawlings
Rawlings Heart of the Hide PRORCM33-23CBP Model 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
Sale price$329.99
Only 2 units left
All-Star
All Star Pro Elite Solid Black Series 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
Sale price$449.95
Only 1 unit left
All-Star
All-Star Pro-Elite Series 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
Sale price$449.95
Only 3 units leftSave $39.98


Wilson
Wilson Fall 2025 A2K 1734 SuperSkin Model 34" Catchers Mitt
Sale price$379.97
Regular price$419.95
Only 2 units leftSave $49.98


Wilson
Wilson Fall 2025 A2000 AW28 SuperSkin Austin Wells Game Model 34" Catchers Mitt
Sale price$279.97
Regular price$329.95
Only 1 unit left

Wilson
Wilson A2000 M23 Glove Day Series Black Edition 33.5" Baseball Catchers Mitt
Sale price$329.95
Only 1 unit leftSave $4.98

Rawlings
Rawlings Select Pro Lite Adley Rutschman SPLCM32AR 32" Youth Baseball Catchers Mitt
Sale price$69.97
Regular price$74.95
Only 2 units leftSave $9.98

Rawlings
Rawlings One Piece 33" Sandlot Series Catcher's Mitt
Sale price$89.97
Regular price$99.95
Only 4 units left
Rawlings
Rawlings Heart of the Hide Yadier Molina PRORYM4C 34" Baseball Catchers Mitt
Sale price$329.99
Only 9 units leftRecently viewed
- Opens in a new window.











